Investment idea generation.

Blog

Our thoughts.

John Casella thoughts on Casella Waste

Don't forget - sign up for our free daily newsletter to stay in the activist investing know. 

As detailed in an Oct. 8 article that ran in the Herald, “Texas firm makes a move on Casella Waste,” Casella Waste Systems Inc. is currently engaged in a proxy contest with JCP Investment Management, a Texas-based activist hedge fund that started accumulating shares of Casella in May 2014 and currently owns approximately 5.7 percent of our shares. JCP, which has no experience whatsoever in the waste management industry and no nexus to the people and communities of Vermont, is trying to get two of its handpicked candidates elected to the Casella Waste board of directors at our 2015 annual meeting of stockholders this November.

I have respected the Herald for many years. However, I am extremely disappointed that I was not approached sooner or given the appropriate time to correct some of the facts before the article was published for all to read. In order to ensure that our customers, stockholders, neighbors and the communities in which we serve are provided with a more accurate portrayal of the facts than what was conveyed by the article, I call your attention to the following:

— Casella Waste filed its definitive proxy statement with the Securities and Exchange Commission on Sept. 22. A chronology of our discussions with JCP can be found in the section titled, “Background of the Contested Solicitation.”

— The article misrepresents JCP’s proxy contest as an attempt to “take over the company.” This leads many people to mistakenly believe this is a takeover battle and that there is the potential for JCP to gain control of the company. That is not the case. This is a proxy election contest for two out of nine seats on our board of directors.

— We have a strong and highly qualified board committed to serving the best interests of our stockholders, which includes numerous residents of the Vermont communities we serve. The Casella board is composed of nine highly qualified and experienced directors, seven of whom are independent, and boasts a broad and diverse set of skills and experiences.

— Our board has unanimously recommended that our stockholders vote to elect our highly qualified and experienced board nominees, which includes two of the most highly respected veterans of the waste management industry, James E. O’Connor and William P. Hulligan.

— JCP’s founder, James C. Pappas, is one of JCP’s proposed board candidates. Mr. Pappas is an activist investor with no waste management industry experience and his public company board experience has mostly been limited to food-related companies and an exploration stage Canadian mining company that had its stock traded in the Over the Counter (OTC) market and that ceased operations in 2013 during Mr. Pappas’ board tenure after failing to identify a suitable strategic option.

— In an attempt to distract our stockholders so they don’t notice that JCP’s proposed director candidates lack any relevant experience helpful to the Casella board’s efforts to drive stockholder value, Mr. Pappas has also made numerous unfounded accusations regarding Casella Waste. He questions the business relationship between Casella Waste and Casella Construction, a relationship that we have been very transparent about in our SEC filings. I want to set the record straight: All of Casella Waste’s major contracts are put to bid, and the business is awarded to the party with the lowest qualified offer. As a result of Casella Construction being awarded some of our jobs following its submission of the lowest bid and a stringent review process, Casella Waste Systems has saved approximately $14 million. In our definitive proxy statement, we carefully describe the stringent review process we follow for related party transactions and how our independent bidding process ensures that Casella gets the best value while maintaining a diverse vendor base. In short, we always conduct a fair and diligent process at arm’s length when outsourcing work related to our equipment or property — no exceptions.

This has been an exciting year for Casella Waste, and we are very proud of the significant progress and momentum we have achieved in executing on our strategy, improving our financial and operating performance and positioning Casella for long-term growth and profitability. As a result of the transformative actions we undertook beginning two and a half years ago, the company as a whole is doing well, and Wall Street has taken notice. We believe strongly that we are pursuing the right strategic path — a testament to our entire team’s work ethic.

Furthermore, along with our employees, for whom I am eternally grateful, I know there are many stockholders and community members who support us, and I sincerely thank them.

We are confident our company will move past this unfortunate distraction and are looking forward to maintaining our energy and attention on what truly matters — serving our customers and communities and the people who make Casella Waste the company I am so proud to be a part of.

-John W. Casella is chairman and CEO of Casella Waste Systems Inc.

BWICasella Waste, JCP Investment